Barriers to Implementing Evidence-Based Practice in Collaborative Healthcare Settings.

by

Title:

Barriers to Implementing Evidence-Based Practice in Collaborative Healthcare Settings

Introduction

The successful implementation of evidence-based practice (EBP) in healthcare requires a collaborative effort among stakeholders from different units and disciplines. However, various barriers can hinder the integration of EBP into clinical settings, with collaboration being a prominent challenge. This paper aims to explore the impact of collaboration as a significant barrier to implementing EBP in healthcare settings where child and adult providers must work together. The identification of these barriers will provide insights into potential strategies to improve collaboration and enhance EBP adoption.

Barriers to Implementing Evidence-Based Practice

  1. Organizational/Unit Culture and Attitude Towards Change One of the key barriers to implementing EBP is the prevailing culture within the healthcare organization or unit. A culture resistant to change may discourage healthcare providers from adopting new evidence-based interventions or approaches. This resistance could stem from a lack of appreciation for the benefits of EBP, misconceptions about its value, or an aversion to departing from established practices. It is essential for leaders and stakeholders to promote a culture that encourages open-mindedness and a willingness to embrace evidence-based changes (Forsman et al., 2019).
  2. Resource Availability, Equipment/Software/Data Availability, and Budgetary Constraints Implementing EBP often requires investment in resources, including technology, data systems, and training materials. In collaborative healthcare settings, the need for shared resources across child and adult providers may exacerbate the challenges related to resource allocation. Budgetary constraints can also limit the ability to procure necessary equipment and software. Without sufficient resources, it becomes challenging to access and utilize evidence effectively, hindering the integration of EBP (Titler et al., 2019).
  3. Time Constraints Healthcare professionals are often faced with demanding work schedules, and the pressure to attend to numerous patients can limit the time available to engage in EBP activities. Collaborative settings may require additional time for communication, coordination, and joint decision-making, further intensifying the time constraints for providers. Limited time may deter healthcare providers from actively seeking out and implementing evidence-based interventions, reducing the overall adoption of EBP (Melnyk & Fineout-Overholt, 2019).
  4. Organizational/Unit Clearance Requirements In collaborative healthcare settings involving child and adult providers, decision-making processes may involve multiple layers of approval and clearance within each unit or discipline. Complex clearance requirements can lead to delays in implementing EBP interventions, and conflicting clearance procedures may hamper effective collaboration. Streamlining and aligning clearance processes across units can help alleviate this barrier (Forsman et al., 2019).
  5. Inadequate Knowledge and Skills, Weak Beliefs About the Value of EBP, and Lack of EBP Mentors Healthcare providers must possess the necessary knowledge and skills to effectively implement evidence-based interventions. In collaborative settings, variations in educational backgrounds and training among child and adult providers can influence their readiness to adopt EBP. Weak beliefs about the value of EBP may also contribute to resistance in accepting evidence-based changes. Moreover, the absence of experienced EBP mentors to guide and support the implementation process can hinder successful adoption (Titler et al., 2019).

DQ2: Overcoming Time Constraints and Overwhelming Care Loads in Implementing Evidence-Based Practice in Nursing

Implementing evidence-based practice (EBP) in nursing is essential for providing high-quality, patient-centered care. However, several obstacles or barriers can hinder the successful integration of EBP into nursing practice. Among these barriers, two significant challenges are the lack of time and overwhelming care loads faced by nurses (Melnyk & Fineout-Overholt, 2018).

  1. Lack of Time Nurses often work in fast-paced and demanding healthcare environments, leaving limited time for engaging in EBP activities. Daily responsibilities, such as direct patient care, documentation, and coordination with other healthcare professionals, can consume a significant portion of nurses’ schedules. Consequently, finding time to access and critically appraise evidence, as well as implementing evidence-based interventions, becomes challenging.

To overcome this barrier, healthcare organizations can support nurses by incorporating EBP into their workflow and providing dedicated time for EBP-related activities. Implementing designated EBP committees or champions can also help streamline the process and ensure that nurses have the necessary resources and time to participate in evidence-based initiatives. Additionally, offering continuing education and training on efficient evidence searching and appraisal techniques can empower nurses to use their time effectively while engaging in EBP.

  1. Overwhelming Care Loads The increasing complexity of healthcare needs and the growing patient population can lead to overwhelming care loads for nurses. Balancing the provision of quality care while staying updated with the latest evidence can be a significant challenge. In such situations, nurses may resort to relying on traditional practices or routines, overlooking the potential benefits of evidence-based interventions.

To address this barrier, healthcare institutions should prioritize the well-being of nursing staff and consider workload distribution strategies that allow for reasonable workloads. Adequate staffing levels, workload assessments, and support from management can help prevent burnout and ensure nurses have the capacity to integrate EBP into their practice. Encouraging interdisciplinary collaboration can also help distribute responsibilities and foster a team-based approach to implementing evidence-based care.

Conclusion

Collaborative healthcare settings, involving child and adult providers, face unique challenges in implementing evidence-based practice. Among the barriers identified, collaboration stands out as a major obstacle due to the involvement of a larger stakeholder group and different leadership, potentially leading to decreased support for EBP initiatives. Understanding and addressing these barriers are crucial for promoting successful EBP adoption and ultimately improving the quality of care provided to patients.

References:

  1. Forsman, H., Rudman, A., & Gustavsson, P. (2019). The use of evidence-based practice among nurses in residential care facilities: Associations with individual and organizational characteristics. Worldviews on Evidence-Based Nursing, 16(3), 211-218.
  2. Melnyk, B. M., & Fineout-Overholt, E. (2019). Evidence-Based Practice in Nursing & Healthcare: A Guide to Best Practice (4th ed.). Wolters Kluwer.
  3. Titler, M. G., Ardery, G., & Tromp, K. (2019). Implementation of evidence-based practice in an academic medical center: A leadership approach. Nursing Administration Quarterly, 43(3), 236-245.